Now, as an israeli, i went to explore this phenomenon here. The book is more than four hundred pages long and seeks to explain orthodox attrition and what is to be done about it. Nevertheless, it is the only book so far that seems to address the issue of why people leave orthodoxy. Observant jews leave judaismhow to respond to the challenge by faranak margolese 2005.
Faranak margolese is a writer and best sellingauthor of the works off the derech and hayotzim, which explain the phenomenon of observant people leaving judaism. Rabbi gluck, who serves as administrator of project y. Based on extensive interviews with rabbis, educators, psychologists, and atrisk experts, this groundbreaking book reveals the multilayered reasons for the defection. This groundbreaking book by faranak margolese examines why orthodox jews stop practicing judaism, confronting one of the most pressing issues in. Off the derech, translated as off the path, is the term used within the. Why observant jews leave judaismhow to respond to the challenge. Faranak margolese author of off the derech goodreads. This is where we shape the futures of jewery and jews. Using questionnaires, extensive interviews with psychologists and rabbis, an. Is the author of this book reputable regarding discussion.
A major contribution, yes, but hardly the last word, and hardly as. The term applies to a broad range of exorthodox jews, including those who leave hasidic communities, ultraorthodox or haredi communities, and modern orthodox communities. Finding your own way on the religious path haaretz israel. Early in my reading of faranak margoleses book off the derech a question began to bother me. Off the derech kindle edition by faranak margolese. Off the derech is the phrase used within the orthodox jewish communit. Review of off the derech by faranak margolese blogger. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading off the derech. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. One of the many stories quoted by faranak margolese in her book off the derech is about a man named david who grew up in an orthodox home, but eventually abandoned observance. Off the derech download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl, mobi.
Off the derech kindle edition by margolese, faranak. Why observant jews leave judaism she provides a harsh realization as to the scope of the problem. Leaving hasidism, keeping my family by chaya deitsch is written, laced with love, as is off the derech by faranak margolese. Yet, i could also see limitations in such a theory. Using questionnaires, extensive interviews with psychologists and rabbis, and her off the. Against the wall ruthie pearlman whispers ruthie pearlman foundling ruthie pearlman target ruthie pearlman people speak 7 chaim walder people speak 5 chaim walder off the derech faranak margolese samarkand hillel zaltzman what else. I, too, read the book and it does indeed contain some fascinating insights into the off the derech phenomenon. How jewish history, culture, and values shaped the comic book superhero and new yorks hippest rabbi 29. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. Finding your own way on the religious path haaretz. I just finished reading off the derech by faranak margolese, and i thought it was very interesting.
Based on a study which involved over 500 jews who left orthodox judaism, off the derech presents the first comprehensive examination of the causes of defection from. If you guessed it was samuel heilman, though, youd be wrong in this case, its faranak margolese, whose book off the derech is a major contribution to the discussion of teens at risk and the phenomenon of young men and women leaving the world of observance. According to her cited sources, percentages ranging from 525% of children raised in observant homes no longer were keeping some or all normative halakha. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. When pressed to describe his education, he recounts a day in second grade when his teacher played an alleged tape recording of gehennom, or hell. Jews from judaism, and presents solutions to this growing problem for parents, teachers and rabbis. Nov 10, 2011 faranak margolese wrote that one of the the reasons people go off the derech is because they are turned off by people who are closed minded and take extreme positions such as that negia is a. Her central thesis is that people raised orthodox leave orthodoxy go off the derech because of factors in their life which cause them to associate orthodoxy that is to.
She discusses a lot of the causes that drive people off the derech, and does so in a fairly perceptive and truthful manner. Off the derech by faranak margolese, 9781932687439, available at book depository with free delivery worldwide. Sep 11, 2006 she is the author of the highly popular book off the derech, why observent jews leave judaism. Why observant jews leave judaismhow to respond to the challenge by margolese, faranak isbn. In the book is called off the derech by faranak margolese, published by devorah publishing, on page 179 the following is written. Oct 27, 2014 according to faranak margolese off the derech it is mainly because of religious figures who behave negatively false.
Download pdf off the derech free online new books in. New book tries to keep orthodox, well, orthodox jewish. How to respond to the challenge by margolese, faranak isbn. Now my answers, as well as those of 465 other orthodox rebels, are the subject of the book, off the derech. The hidden lives of hasidic rebels by hella winston does a nice job of highlighting some examples of this phenomenon and the underlying issues faced by tracking the lives of a few individuals who took the route. Professor faranak margolese, the greatgranddaughter of the former chief rabbi of tehran and author of off the derech. Great book to understand how to become secular national jew.
Featuring rabbi simcha weinstein, author of, up, up, and oy vey. I read the book her conclusion is essentially that. Based on a study which involved hundreds of people who have gone off the derech, as well as indepth interviews with psychologists, educators, program directors, prominent rabbis and other experts in the field, this groundbreaking book reveals the multilayered causes for defection and presents possible solutions to the growing problem. This groundbreaking book by faranak margolese examines why orthodox jews stop practicing judaism, confronting one of the most pressing issues in the religious jewish world today. To learn more about some reasons why people leave observant judaism, the book off the derech by faranak margolese can be helpful, although many exobservant people disagree with some of the premises and conclusions in the book. Parents and educators around the workd changed the way they raise their children. Off the derech by faranak margolese has been getting some attention, and for good reason. A decade after the bestselling book off the derech became mandatory reading for observant jewish families in chutz laaretz, faranak margolese has written a new israeli edition based on extensive interviews with rabbis, educators, psychologists, and atrisk experts, this groundbreaking book reveals the multilayered reasons for the defection and presents. In the decades after world war ii, with the growth of orthodox jewish society from the ashes, it was assumed that with an observant family and a proper day school education in place, orthodox jewish growth was guaranteed. I, too, read the book and it does indeed contain some fascinating insights into the offthederech phenomenon. Faranak margolese born 1972 is an american writer, best known as the author of off the derech, a book about contemporary assimilation in the orthodox jewish world. Click download or read online button to get off the derech book now.
May 26, 2017 to learn more about some reasons why people leave observant judaism, the book off the derech by faranak margolese can be helpful, although many exobservant people disagree with some of the premises and conclusions in the book. New book tries to keep orthodox, well, orthodox jewish journal. This does not mean we should shy away from such conversations. Off the derech why observant jews leave judaism and how to. Faranak margolese is the author of off the derech 3. This groundbreaking book by faranak margolese examines why orthodox jews stop practicing judaism, confronting one of the most pressing issues in the. The book off the derech is already a bestseller in the united states. Why observant jews leave judaism by faranak margolese devora publishing. Instead, we should acknowledge the difficulties in doing so and move ahead anyway. Im on a 2 month free trial, what jewish books are there. Why observant jews stop practicing judaism, wrote to me, there is very much a rhyme and reason. A decade after the bestselling book off the derech became mandatory reading for observant jewish families in chutz laaretz, faranak margolese has written a new israeli edition. What if the issue being discussed was a familial love of camping and what to do if one of the kids started to not want to go camping.
This book is written from a pertinent but narrow focus. Off the derech is a book that must be read, not only by educators who want to know where we went wrong, but also by parents and teachers who want to know how. A new book seeks to help orthodox parents and educators to return wayward children to the path of strict religious observance. A decade after the bestselling book off the derech became mandatory reading for observant jewish families in chutz laaretz, faranak margolese has written a new israeli edition based on extensive interviews with rabbis, educators, psychologists, and atrisk experts, this groundbreaking book reveals the multilayered reasons for the defection and presents possible solutions. Is the author of this book reputable regarding discussion of. Off the derech why observant jews leave judaism and how. Off the derech is the phrase used within the orthodox jewish community to describe those who have left jewish observance. Off the derech, translated as off the path, is the term used within the orthodox jewish community to describe those who have left jewish observance. Faranak margolese is an american writer, best known as the author of off the derech, a book about contemporary assimilation. Using questionnaires, extensive interviews with psychologists and rabbis, and her off the derech website, the author reveals the multilayered reasons for the defection of so many observant jews from judaism. Whats it like growing up hasidic and then leaving the faith. We must stop treating jewish observance as an allor.
1110 1329 1426 1123 515 1160 370 374 407 348 629 737 1353 1230 718 211 593 390 1268 242 107 1385 1176 1143 1162 991 127 373 138 1202 1451 12 155 248 807 1201 1377 152 523 1289 947 299 1091 802 1177 1458